Who are the different drive types suitable for?

Owners of growing video libraries

If you mainly back up your videos on a home PC that stays in one place, allow room for your existing files, new videos and saved versions. The German Federal Office for Information Security recommends having enough storage for the backups you plan to make.

People with hard-to-replace footage

If your own recordings or project files matter to you, it’s important to have a separate copy and to make sure you can actually restore your files. The German Federal Office for Information Security points out that you should also test restoring your data.

People who often copy large files

If you regularly transfer large video files, transfer time and the entire connection between the drive and your computer are important factors. The speed you can achieve also depends on the ports and cables you use.

What should you consider when choosing?

Desktop HDD

A good fit if: Your library needs plenty of space and the drive will mainly stay connected to your home PC.

Worth considering: Depending on the model, you’ll need a permanent spot for it and a power supply. The 3.5-inch HDDs tested in the COMPUTER BILD comparison ranged from 8 to 20 TB; the rankings apply to the specific versions tested.

Portable HDD

A good fit if: You’d like to occasionally move the drive to another secure location and don’t transfer large files particularly often.

Worth considering: The 2.5-inch test group in the COMPUTER BILD comparison included drives up to 6 TB. Check that the specific version can hold everything you plan to back up.

External SSD

A good fit if: You often move large files between compatible computers and an SSD with the capacity you need is right for you.

Worth considering: Samsung quotes sequential read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s for the German 4-TB version of the T7 Shield. These maximum speeds require a suitable host device, compatible cables and UASP.

What you need What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Capacity for your existing files and future growth Work out how much storage you’re already using, how much you expect to add and how many versions you want to keep. Check the capacity of the specific version. The manufacturer’s TB figure may differ from what your operating system displays. If my collection is growing, I want room for my existing files and the videos I plan to add. That’s why around 33 % of consumers put having enough space first.
A separate backup you can restore Decide which files and versions to back up. Keep the backup separate and test whether you can restore a file. If my recordings or project files are hard to replace, I want to be able to restore a separate copy when I need it. That’s why around 27 % of consumers prioritise recoverability.
Time needed for frequent video transfers Consider how often you transfer large files, then check that the drive, computer port and cable meet the requirements for any quoted speed. If I often copy large files, I want to take transfer time and the whole connection into account. Around 20 % of consumers prioritise copying speed.
Connection, file system and where you’ll keep the drive Check that the USB port, included cable, power requirements and file system are compatible with your PC. Also check what your backup software requires. If the drive needs to work with my home PC and might occasionally be moved, I’ll check its connections, power supply and file system. Around 20 % of consumers prioritise this practical compatibility.

Avoiding mistakes when choosing and backing up

  • Moving your only copy of a video to an external drive

    If that drive fails, you won’t have anything to restore your files from unless you have another copy.

    Keep your working files separate from your backup and test restoring a file.

    Keeping a genuinely separate copy may require additional storage.

  • Choosing an SSD based only on its advertised maximum speed

    The sequential maximum speeds Samsung quotes for the T7 Shield require a compatible host device, a suitable cable and UASP. They don’t necessarily reflect the speed of your own transfers.

    First check how much you need to back up, then make sure your entire connection meets the requirements for the specific speed quoted.

  • Treating a desktop HDD and a portable drive as if they were the same

    The desktop models described here come with a power supply, so a stationary drive will also need a power socket.

    Before you buy, decide where you’ll keep the drive and how often you’ll want to move or put it away.

Brands and model ranges at a glance

Seagate

Expansion Desktop is a range of desktop HDDs for larger files and backups.

  • In COMPUTER BILD’s 3.5-inch hard drive test, the 16 TB Expansion Desktop version tested came first on 10 July 2026. The result applies to that specific version.
  • Seagate specifies a power supply and USB connection for the desktop range. According to COMPUTER BILD, the tested 16-TB model did not include a USB hub.

Western Digital

My Book and WD Elements Desktop are ranges of desktop drives for backups, with different features.

  • The 14-TB and 12-TB My Book versions tested by COMPUTER BILD came fourth and fifth in its comparison.
  • In its comparison of specific 4-TB versions, Western Digital lists backup software and a three-year warranty for My Book, and a simpler package and two-year warranty for Elements. Check whether these details apply to the exact version you’re considering.

Samsung

The external T7 Shield is an SSD range for frequent transfers and taking your files with you.

  • For the German 4-TB version, Samsung quotes sequential read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s under specific connection conditions.
  • The IP65 rating was tested under controlled conditions. Samsung says the warranty does not cover damage caused by liquids or dust.

Toshiba

Canvio for Desktop is another range of desktop HDDs, with Toshiba listing versions up to 6 TB.

  • The manufacturer’s website lists a power supply, NTFS as the pre-installed format and a Mac driver.
  • Check that the specific version is compatible with your operating system and has enough capacity for your video library.

Joybuy products for video backups

The Joybuy products below include portable HDDs for use in different locations, a desktop HDD and an external SSD. Compare their capacity and connections with the amount of data you need to back up and your computer.

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C

A good fit if you’re looking for a portable HDD for a video backup that will fit within the stated capacity.

5 TB, 2.5-inch form factor, 240 g and USB-C/USB 3.2 Gen 1.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C

A good fit if you’re looking for a portable HDD and the stated capacity is enough for the backup you plan to make.

4 TB, 2.5-inch form factor, 240 g and USB-C/USB 3.2 Gen 1.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements 2TB Portable, USB-C

WD Elements 2TB Portable, USB-C

A good fit if you want a portable drive powered via USB and 2 TB is enough for the files you plan to back up.

2 TB, 2.5-inch form factor, USB-C and exFAT; according to the product description, no external power supply is required.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements 8TB desktop hard drive, USB 3.0

WD Elements 8TB Desktop, USB 3.0

A good fit for a video backup that will mainly stay in one place, if 8 TB is enough for the files you plan to store.

8 TB, 3.5-inch form factor, USB 3.0 and included power supply. According to the product description, the drive needs to be reformatted for the macOS use described.

View at Joybuy
KEXIN external SSD 256GB, USB 3.1

KEXIN external SSD 256GB, USB 3.1

May be suitable for frequent transfers if 256 GB is enough for the backup you plan to make.

256 GB; the product description quotes speeds of up to 500 MB/s over USB 3.1. Its stated capacity limits how much video footage it can hold.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How much capacity should my backup drive have?

First, work out the size of all the videos and other files you want to back up, then allow space for future growth and any versions you want to keep. The German Federal Office for Information Security recommends having enough storage. Its guidance that a drive used to back up all the data on a PC should be larger than the PC’s storage is not a fixed rule for backing up selected video folders.

Is it enough to move my videos to an external hard drive?

No, not if that leaves you with only one copy. Keep your working files separate from a backup, and test whether you can restore a file. The German Federal Office for Information Security points out that restoring your data needs to work too.

Does my external hard drive need to stay connected all the time?

Not with every backup method. Disconnecting your backup after use and keeping it somewhere safe can help protect it from problems affecting your PC while it’s running. If you use a scheduled backup, you’ll need to make sure the drive is connected in time. The explicit offline backup requirement on the cited German Federal Office for Information Security page applies to organisations in the context of ransomware; it is not a legal requirement for households.

Do I need drive encryption?

If the drive contains personal or confidential videos and could be lost or stolen, consider encryption and make sure you store the recovery key securely. According to the German Federal Office for Information Security, a hard drive password does not necessarily mean that the data is stored in encrypted form.

Can I copy any video file for my personal backup?

There’s no blanket answer. Section 53(1) of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) permits individual copies for private use, subject to certain conditions, and excludes, in particular, works that are obviously unlawful copies or have been made publicly available unlawfully. Section 95a of the UrhG also restricts the circumvention of effective technological protection measures. The German Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice include these provisions in the legislation; whether they apply to a particular file and method of copying depends on where it came from and the terms of its protection.