Which drive is right for you?

Video creators with a desktop archive

If you keep lots of completed projects mainly at one fixed workstation, you’ll need enough capacity and a separate backup. Seagate Germany describes its desktop drives as having a dedicated power supply, while the German Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) recommends keeping backups separate and checking that they can be restored.

Video teams that access projects regularly

If you move projects back to your editing system, consider the connections on the drive, computer and cable as well as its capacity. Samsung Germany and Crucial quote manufacturer speeds for their SSD models, subject to specific connection and testing conditions.

Video creators who transport their projects

If you move project folders between locations or devices, check the portability, connection options and file system of the specific drive. Toshiba Electronics Europe says the Canvio Flex comes with USB-A and USB-C cables, while the BSI stresses that backups must also be restorable.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide whether your projects will mainly be stored in one place, regularly transported or frequently edited again. This will determine the type of drive and the connections you need.

What to consider What to look for Who it matters most to
Capacity for complete projects Add up the size of complete project folders, including their media, and allow for future projects. Check the usable capacity of the specific model. If I need to store complete project folders and allow for future growth, the usable space available is what matters to me. Around 36% of consumers prioritise capacity.
Separate backup and recovery Allow space for an independent copy and try restoring complete project folders. If I want to keep important projects for the long term, I need to be able to access a readable copy even if a drive fails. Around 29% of consumers prioritise backup and recoverability.
Time needed to copy projects back Check that the connections on the drive, computer and cable are compatible. Compare manufacturers’ maximum speeds only under the conditions they specify. If I regularly bring large projects back into my editing workflow, I want to know whether my devices’ interfaces are compatible with the drive. Around 21% of consumers prioritise access speed.
Transport and switching between devices Check the cable, host connections and file system for the devices you actually use. Read the stated protection ratings and their conditions. If I move project folders between work locations or computers, I need a drive that I can connect and read wherever I am. Around 14% of consumers prioritise portability.

Common archiving mistakes

  • Keeping the only archive copy on a new drive

    Even a new drive can fail, and saved files are not automatically guaranteed to remain readable.

    Keep a separate copy and try restoring a complete project before deleting the originals.

  • Treating RAID as an independent backup

    The BSI explains that mirroring data does not replace a backup: changes, accidental overwriting or malware can affect mirrored copies too. RAID 0 also offers no drive redundancy.

    Check the RAID mode and usable capacity, but plan to keep an additional copy outside the enclosure.

  • Assuming manufacturer speeds guarantee copy times

    Maximum SSD speed claims apply under specific connection and testing conditions. They don’t automatically tell you how quickly a complete project folder will transfer.

    Check the USB capabilities of the drive, computer and cable, and assess manufacturer speeds only within the stated conditions.

  • Assuming a rugged enclosure protects against data loss

    Enclosure protection and an independent backup serve different purposes. Samsung notes that liquid and dust damage are not covered by the warranty for the T7 Shield.

    Read the protection conditions for the specific model and keep an additional copy of any transported project folders on a separate storage device.

Brands and product ranges to consider

Seagate

The Expansion Desktop range is designed for large media libraries stored in one place. Seagate Germany lists models up to 28 TB with a dedicated power supply.

  • The desktop design is an option for archives where capacity matters more than portability.
  • It needs a power supply and a permanent place to sit. Check the terms of any data recovery service for the specific model; such a service does not guarantee that your data can be recovered.

Western Digital

The My Book Duo is an example of a desktop option with multiple drives for large data collections. The 20-TB model described appears on an Austrian product page and does not confirm availability in Germany.

  • Western Digital describes the 20-TB model as offering RAID 0 and backup software.
  • RAID 0 is not a redundant archive copy. The BSI also advises that mirroring does not replace a separate backup.

Samsung

The T7 Shield is a portable SSD range; the specific model listed, MU-PE4T0S/EU, has a capacity of 4 TB.

  • Samsung quotes read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s for this model when the host and cable support USB 3.2 Gen 2 and UASP is enabled.
  • These are manufacturer figures under specified connection conditions, not measured speeds for complete project folders. Samsung gives the model an IP65 rating based on controlled tests and excludes liquid and dust damage from the warranty.

Crucial

Crucial describes the X10 Pro as a portable SSD for a range of uses and lists models with capacities of 1, 2 and 4 TB.

  • Under its own testing conditions, Crucial quotes read speeds of up to 2.100 MB/s and write speeds of up to 2.000 MB/s for the X10 Pro.
  • These manufacturer figures do not guarantee the speed you’ll get when transferring complete video projects. Check the connections and conditions for the specific model too.

Toshiba

The Canvio Flex is a portable HDD range for use with compatible devices. Toshiba Electronics Europe lists a 4-TB model.

  • The product range described includes USB-A and USB-C cables.
  • Still check that the host device and file system are compatible, and that the transfer speed meets your needs.

LaCie

Rugged USB-C is a portable HDD range for creative work on the go. Seagate lists models with capacities of up to 5 TB.

  • Seagate describes the enclosure as protecting against certain hazards and states that the model can withstand drops from heights of up to 1,2 metres.
  • These claims apply under the stated conditions and do not make a second, separate copy of your projects unnecessary.

Joybuy products for desktop archives

These external desktop HDDs are suited to large project folders that are mainly archived at a fixed workstation. Make sure you also keep a separate backup copy.

WD Elements 6 TB desktop hard drive

WD Elements desktop hard drive, 6 TB

For large project folders you want to archive in one place, provided the usable capacity suits your collection.

Listed with 6 TB, USB 3.0 and an external power supply.

Reformatting is required for the described use with macOS; check the file system before use.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements 12 TB desktop hard drive

WD Elements desktop hard drive, 12 TB

For large media libraries stored in one place, provided the capacity can hold your complete project folders.

Listed with 12 TB, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and an external power supply.

Reformatting is required for the described use with macOS; check the file system before use.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements 10 TB desktop hard drive

WD Elements desktop hard drive, 10 TB

For large project folders kept at a fixed workstation, if the capacity of this model suits your archive.

Listed with 10 TB, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and an external power supply.

Reformatting is required for the described use with macOS; check the file system before use.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements 8 TB desktop hard drive

WD Elements desktop hard drive, 8 TB

For video projects stored in one place, if you need the stated capacity for your complete folders.

Listed with 8 TB, USB 3.0 and an external power supply.

Reformatting is required for the described use with macOS; check the file system before use.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements 20 TB desktop hard drive

WD Elements desktop hard drive, 20 TB

For very large project folders you want to archive in one place, provided the capacity suits your data collection.

Listed with 20 TB, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and a power supply included.

A single drive is not a substitute for a separate backup copy.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I work out how much storage I need before buying an archive drive?

Add up the storage needed for your complete project folders and allow for future projects. Compare this with the usable capacity of the specific model: manufacturers quote TB in decimal, and formatting uses some of the storage.

Do I need to reformat the drive for Windows and Mac?

Not necessarily. Before making your first archive copy, check the file system and the read and write requirements of the computers you’ll be using. Claims about cross-device use apply to the relevant product range and compatible devices. Back up any existing data before considering reformatting.

Is a RAID enclosure or data recovery service enough for a backup?

No. The BSI distinguishes data mirroring from a backup because changes, accidental overwriting or malware can affect multiple drives too. Keep a separate copy and test that you can restore it.

What ongoing requirements and service terms should I consider?

A desktop HDD needs a suitable place to sit and a power supply. You’ll also need to allow for storage space for separate backup copies. Check the warranty and the terms of any data recovery service available for the specific model and region. Such a service is no substitute for keeping a second copy yourself.

Does an archive containing personal video data need to be encrypted?

That depends, among other things, on who processes the data and the level of risk. The GDPR requires controllers and processors to use technical and organisational measures appropriate to the risk. The German Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information particularly emphasises encryption when transporting portable storage devices. This does not mean that every personal video archive must use a particular encrypted drive.