Which recorder is right for you?

Club historian recording one storyteller

When one seated person is telling the story, capturing their voice clearly and keeping the process simple are often more important than having lots of extra features. The guidance from the Archives of Contemporary History at ETH Zurich highlights microphone placement and room acoustics as important parts of setting up a recording.

Interviewer recording longer recollections

For a longer conversation, the recording format, available storage and power supply should suit your planned session. Battery-life figures don’t necessarily apply to every format, so check the conditions for the format you intend to use.

Club archivist

If you plan to review, edit or preserve interviews later, consider the recording format, export options and backup of the original files together. The Archives of Contemporary History at ETH Zurich recommends PCM in WAV format for long-term digital preservation.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide whether you need to capture just the seated storyteller or make other voices easy to hear as well. Then make a short test recording in the intended location and check storage, power and file export for your chosen recording format.

Consideration What to check before buying Who is this particularly important for?
Clear main voice Listen to a test recording from the intended seat; check the microphone position and whether a suitable external microphone can be connected. If I want to understand the storyteller clearly, I’ll also check the set-up for table and room noise. Around 36% of consumers put clear audio of the main speaker first.
Long recording without interruption Check the available storage and power supply for your chosen format, and do a test run before the interview. If you want to capture a continuous conversation, make sure the storage and power supply are right for the session. Around 29% of consumers prioritise recording a complete session.
Files for the club archive Check WAV/PCM recording and file transfer; keep a separate copy of the original file. If I want to edit or preserve a recording later, I need a suitable format and a reliable way to export it. Around 21% of consumers consider archive-ready original files their top priority.
Other voices in the conversation Test all the planned seats; if you need to edit voices separately, check that the recorder, inputs and microphones work together. If you want questions or contributions from other club members to be audible too, test the recording with everyone who will be taking part. Around 14% of consumers prioritise capturing several audible voices.

Common recording misconceptions

  • 32-bit float or noise filters solve every recording problem

    Recording features can’t replace good microphone placement or a quiet room. Noise caused by a poor set-up can still be heard in the recording.

    Start by listening to a test recording from the intended location and adjust the set-up. Then decide whether extra features or an external microphone would help with your recording.

    A stand or a suitable external microphone may require extra set-up.

  • The maximum recording time also applies to WAV

    The Philips DVT4115 manual states a recording time of up to 36 hours for MP3 at 8 kbit/s. This figure doesn’t apply to WAV recordings across the board.

    Check battery life and storage for the format you actually plan to use, and test your recording set-up before the interview.

  • Permission to record automatically includes permission to publish

    Recording words spoken in private and using or publishing them later are separate matters. Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) covers the unauthorised recording of words spoken in private; data protection issues relating to later use should be considered separately.

    Before the conversation, clarify whether it will be recorded and what the recording might be used for. Make sure any potential publication is explicitly covered in your agreement, and check the data protection requirements.

Brands to consider

Zoom

The H1essential may be worth considering if you want to mount a handheld recorder on a stand or connect an external microphone.

  • Zoom lists 32-bit float, a mono mode and stand mounting for the H1essential.
  • These features won’t correct poor microphone placement or a room with a lot of echo.

Tascam

The DR-05XP is an option if you’re looking for a handheld recorder with several recording formats and an external microphone input.

  • Tascam lists WAV recording at 16-bit, 24-bit or 32-bit float, as well as MP3 and an external microphone input.
  • A single microphone input doesn’t confirm that two clip-on microphones can be recorded on separate channels. Check that your specific set-up is compatible.

Sony

The ICD-UX570 is aimed at buyers who want to listen back to voice recordings and transfer files to a computer.

  • Sony lists Linear PCM/MP3, USB charging and A/B repeat.
  • A test recording in the intended location will help you judge whether playback is clear enough for your interview.

OM SYSTEM

The WS-883 may be worth considering if you want straightforward operation and direct USB file transfer.

  • OM SYSTEM lists a simple operating mode, 8 GB of internal storage, and MP3 and mono PCM recording.
  • According to the manufacturer, PCM is mono on this model. Check that the formats meet your archive’s requirements.

Philips

The VoiceTracer DVT4115 is an option if internal storage and WAV/PCM recording are important to your choice.

  • Philips lists 8 GB of internal storage and WAV/PCM. The manual states a recording time of up to 36 hours for MP3 at 8 kbit/s.
  • This recording-time figure applies to that MP3 format and can’t be applied to WAV across the board.

Joybuy products for this topic

The Joybuy products below are compact voice recorders suited to the scenario of a sit-down conversation. Compare the features listed for each with your recording, file export and editing needs.

PLAUD Note Pro Voice Recorder, 64 GB, Black

PLAUD Note Pro Voice Recorder, 64 GB, Black

Could be suitable for a conversation if an integrated microphone and storage for longer recordings are important to you.

64 GB storage; four MEMS microphones; stated recording time: 30 hours; compatible with Android and iOS.

Joybuy
Digital Voice Recorder, 64 GB, with Transcription Function

Digital Voice Recorder, 64 GB, with Transcription Function

The product description lists interviews as a possible use; before buying, check whether the stated features suit your recording and post-production process.

64 GB storage; stated recording time: 36 hours.

Joybuy
Rexsun L15, Portable Digital Voice Recorder, 64 GB

Rexsun L15, Portable Digital Voice Recorder, 64 GB

The description lists interviews as a possible use and USB transfer for moving files afterwards.

Two omnidirectional microphones; WAV recording; 64 GB TF card; stated recording time: up to 22 hours.

Joybuy
Rexsun L810, Digital Voice Recorder with One-Button Recording

Rexsun L810, Digital Voice Recorder

The description lists interviews as a possible use, along with features for transferring and finding files.

MP3 and WAV recording; stated continuous recording time: up to 35 hours; A-B repeat; USB-C file transfer; file timestamps.

Joybuy
Rexsun L357, Portable Digital Voice Recorder, 128 GB

Rexsun L357, Portable Digital Voice Recorder, 128 GB

The description lists interviews as a possible use and WAV recording for those choosing a particular file format.

128 GB storage; WAV recording; USB-C file transfer; stated continuous recording time: up to 35 hours.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I simply record a conversation for the club’s history?

Discuss the recording with the person telling their story beforehand. Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) concerns the unauthorised recording of words spoken in private and the handling of such a recording. Later use, particularly publication, should be considered separately. If you rely on consent, the guidance from the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information says it must be freely given.

Where should I place the recorder for a sit-down interview?

Choose a quiet room with as little echo as possible, and test the recording from the intended seat. The Archives of Contemporary History at ETH Zurich recommends positioning the microphone towards the interviewee on a stand if possible, as writing, glasses or tapping on the table can all be picked up in the recording.

Which format is best for a club archive?

If you want to use an original recording over the long term, the Archives of Contemporary History at ETH Zurich recommends PCM in WAV format. Check that your specific device can record in this format and export the files, and keep a separate copy before deleting recordings or resetting the device.

What happens if the recorder develops a fault, and what about the manufacturer’s warranty?

Your statutory rights against the seller are separate from a voluntary manufacturer’s warranty. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, if a product is faulty, you should first request a remedy, such as a repair or replacement; a manufacturer’s warranty is subject to its own terms and conditions.