Who’s listening in the book club?

Online listeners in a chatty room

You’re listening to the group on a device and want to hear fewer voices from your immediate surroundings. Fit and isolation matter more to you than hearing as much of the ambient sound as possible. RTINGS.com highlights noise isolation and the reduction of office conversations as useful things to check.

Members chatting in person

You want to keep hearing people sitting beside you, or switch quickly between book club audio and conversations in the room. Open-back headphones or an accessible transparency mode could work well. Sony describes the open design of the LinkBuds Open, while Bose explains the Aware mode on the first-generation QuietComfort Ultra Headphones.

Active speakers in the online group

You want to do more than listen: you also want to be heard clearly when there are conversations in the background. So check the microphone separately from the noise isolation at your ears. RTINGS.com notes that microphones vary in how they handle background voices.

What should you look for?

Closed-back over-ear headphones with ANC

A good choice if: You’re listening to book club members online and want to hear as little as possible of the conversations in your own room.

The trade-off: Noise isolation can also make it harder to hear people in the room when you want to. Check the fit, particularly if you wear glasses.

Closed-back headphones with transparency mode

A good choice if: You want to switch between the audio stream and conversations with people beside you. Bose describes the Aware mode on the first-generation QuietComfort Ultra Headphones.

The trade-off: Letting in ambient sound also makes unwanted conversations audible again.

Open wireless earbuds

A good choice if: Your book club mostly meets in the same room and you want to listen to audio without shutting yourself off from your surroundings. Sony describes the open-ring design of the LinkBuds Open.

The trade-off: Open-back headphones aren’t designed to block out conversations in the room.

Wireless headset for active online participation

A good choice if: You speak regularly and want your contributions to come through clearly, even when people are talking beside you.

The trade-off: Noise isolation for you and the microphone’s handling of background noise are different features. Check microphone tests with background voices.

First, decide whether you want to hear voices coming from a stream or from the room. Then consider whether you’ll be speaking and how long you plan to wear the headphones.

What matters What to look for Who will find this most important?
Understanding streamed voices over conversations Check independent voice-isolation tests and how the ear cushions fit; the fit may be different if you wear glasses. If I’m following an online group in a chatty room, I want to hear less of the distracting conversations. Around 36 % of consumers put blocking out streamed voices first.
Hearing conversations in the same room Weigh up open-back headphones and a switchable transparency mode; try using the controls during playback. If the book club members are sitting beside me, I want to keep hearing what they’re saying rather than being completely cut off from my surroundings. Around 29 % of consumers prioritise listening in to conversations in person.
Making your own contributions clear Look at microphone tests with competing voices and check how calls work on the device you plan to use. If I’m speaking in an online group, I want others to understand me despite background conversations. Around 21 % of consumers prioritise how clearly their voice comes through.
Staying comfortable through longer sessions Check the fit for yourself and compare battery-life figures for the mode you’ll actually use. If I’m listening for a long time, a comfortable fit and enough battery life matter to me—not just the manufacturer’s figure. Around 14 % of consumers put comfort and battery life first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming ANC means a good microphone for your voice

    Reducing the noise you hear and making your voice clear to others are two separate jobs.

    If you’ll be speaking, also look for microphone tests that include background conversations.

  • Choosing maximum isolation when book club members are sitting beside you

    A noise-isolating listening mode can make voices in the room harder to hear. On the other hand, open-back headphones let unwanted sounds through too.

    First decide which voices you want to hear from your device and which from the room.

  • Assuming the same product name means the same generation or version

    The model generation and design matter for the features described. Bose’s mode instructions specifically refer to the first-generation QuietComfort Ultra Headphones.

    Before you buy, check the full model name, generation and design.

Key brands at a glance

Sony

Sony caters for different listening situations with the closed-back WH-1000XM6 and the open LinkBuds Open.

  • RTINGS.com reports that the WH-1000XM6 reduces the sound of office conversations. Sony describes the open-ring design of the LinkBuds Open as a way to hear ambient sounds.
  • RTINGS.com notes that the WH-1000XM6’s shallow ear cushions may not seal properly, particularly if you wear glasses. The open design of the LinkBuds Open doesn’t guarantee clearer speech in noisy surroundings.

Bose

According to Bose, the first-generation QuietComfort Ultra Headphones offer separate Quiet and Aware modes for different listening situations.

  • Bose describes Aware as a transparency mode and Quiet as a noise-cancelling mode.
  • These details apply to the generation named and don’t prove independent superiority or that other generations have identical features.

Sennheiser

According to the manufacturer, the MOMENTUM 4 Wireless combines adaptive ANC with a transparency mode, making it an option to consider for longer sessions.

  • Sennheiser quotes up to 60 hours of battery life on a full charge.
  • The manufacturer’s figure doesn’t tell you whether the ear cushions will fit you or whether voices will remain clear in your particular room.

JBL

JBL describes the Live 780NC as closed-back over-ear headphones with ANC and a microphone for calls.

  • JBL’s product description lists ANC and a microphone for calls.
  • JBL’s claims about voice quality come from the manufacturer. If people will be talking at the same time in your book club, a microphone test under those conditions will be more useful.

Joybuy products for book club

These wireless headphones are aimed mainly at listening when people are talking in the room, and switching between book club audio and ambient sound. The selection includes over-ear models and earbuds.

Sennheiser MOMENTUM 5 Wireless, Denim Blue

Sennheiser MOMENTUM 5 Wireless, Denim Blue

Could suit you if you’re looking for closed-back over-ear headphones with ANC for listening to book club members online.

Product details: 8 microphones, Dolby Atmos, Bluetooth 5.4, up to 57 hours of battery life and a replaceable battery.

View at Joybuy
1MORE SonoFlow MAX (Upgraded HQ51), HQ60

1MORE SonoFlow MAX (Upgraded HQ51), HQ60

Could suit you if you’re looking for over-ear headphones with ANC to hear online voices over conversations in the room.

Product details: 50 dB ANC, up to 105 hours of battery life and THX Spatial Audio.

View at Joybuy
Apple AirPods Max, Blue

Apple AirPods Max, Blue

Could suit you if you want to use ANC for online book club voices and listen in to conversations in the room when needed.

Product details: ANC, transparency mode and USB-C charging case.

View at Joybuy
Sony WH-CH720N, White

Sony WH-CH720N, White

Could suit you if you want to use ANC for online voices and hear your surroundings when needed with an Ambient Sound mode.

Product details: weighs 192 g and offers up to 35 hours of battery life.

View at Joybuy
HUAWEI FreeBuds Pro 4, Black

HUAWEI FreeBuds Pro 4, Black

Could suit you if you prefer earbuds to over-ear headphones and want ANC for online book club voices.

Product details: wireless earbuds with ANC, up to 33 hours of battery life and compatibility with iOS and Android.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does ANC help if background conversations are already part of the book club stream?

No. A headphone isolation test measures external sound reaching your ears. It can’t tell you whether voices that are already mixed into the audio you’re playing can be separated out. In that case, first check the recording or call source.

How do I set up headphones so I can hear people beside me from time to time?

Set up the ambient sound mode on your chosen model and try switching modes during playback. For the first-generation QuietComfort Ultra Headphones, Bose describes selecting the mode with a button or in the app. Sony describes assigning a button through Sound Connect on the WH-1000XM6.

Should I turn the volume up if conversations are drowning out the book club voices?

Not as a long-term solution. The World Health Organization recommends keeping the volume low and using well-fitting, noise-cancelling headphones to reduce the need to turn them up in noisy surroundings. The strain on your hearing depends on both volume and listening time.

What should I know if an online purchase in Germany turns out to be faulty?

Your statutory consumer rights are claims against the seller and are separate from any voluntary guarantee. If a product is faulty, the first step may be a repair or replacement. Online purchases also generally come with a separate 14-day right to cancel. The Verbraucherzentrale explains the differences.

Can I wear these headphones while driving a vehicle in Germany?

Section 23(1) of the German Road Traffic Regulations requires drivers to ensure their hearing is not impaired by devices. This does not establish either a blanket ban on headphones or blanket permission to use every ANC setting. What matters is whether your hearing is impaired during the particular journey. The regulation is published by the Federal Ministry of Justice on its Laws on the Internet website.