Who can benefit from a NAS?

Workshop leaders using several devices

If several authorised computers need the same workshop files, storing them centrally on your own network can save you from having to keep separate copies in sync. Synology describes the DS223j as a place to store documents and other files.

Organisers receiving materials on USB drives

If you regularly receive materials on USB storage devices, check that the specific NAS model supports the import method you want and that you can set up the destination folder as needed. QNAP documents a USB copy button for the TS-233, while Synology lists the DS223j as a model that supports USB Copy.

People responsible for sensitive materials

When files contain personal information, it’s important to decide who can access which files and what safeguards are appropriate for your particular use. The German Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information explains the relevant requirements in relation to the processing involved.

What should you look for when choosing one?

First, work out whether several devices need a shared network drive or whether one computer will copy files occasionally. Then plan the specific USB import process, a separate recovery copy and the access permissions you’ll need.

Consideration What to check before buying Who needs to consider this?
Shared storage Check local file-sharing options and access from the devices you intend to use. If several authorised computers need the same up-to-date workshop files, I want shared storage instead of scattered copies. Around 28% of consumers prioritise sharing access on a local network.
USB import Check model support, the file system recognised, the destination folder and how existing files are handled. Synology only recognises USB or SD devices with a supported file system. If materials regularly arrive on a USB drive, I want to import them reliably to the right place. Around 22% of consumers put USB import first.
Recovery Plan a separate backup destination, a backup schedule and a recovery test. Don’t treat RAID as a replacement for a backup. The BSI distinguishes mirroring from data backup. If files are accidentally deleted or changed, I want to be able to restore them from another copy. Around 22% of consumers prioritise being able to recover their files.
Access to sensitive files Set up user accounts, shared-folder permissions and appropriate safeguards for your particular use. If materials contain personal information, I want to limit access to the people authorised to see it. Around 17% of consumers prioritise controlled access.
Day-to-day effort Check what’s included and which drives are compatible with the specific product. Also allow for a separate backup and ongoing maintenance. If I only copy files occasionally, I don’t want to set up a more complex system than my process requires. Around 11% of consumers prioritise keeping set-up and maintenance effort to a minimum.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking RAID mirroring for an independent backup

    With mirroring, changes can affect both drives. The BSI points out that RAID mirroring is no substitute for data backup.

    Plan a separate copy as well, and test whether you can restore a file from it.

    A separate backup drive and regular recovery tests take extra time and planning.

  • Assuming USB synchronisation is risk-free

    The synchronisation mode documented by QNAP can delete files from the destination if they aren’t present in the source.

    First, check the copy direction and mode using unimportant test files, then check the destination folder.

  • Assuming a NAS enclosure is ready to use straight away

    Synology doesn’t list any hard drives as included with the DS223j. A separate holder is required for 2.5-inch drives.

    Before buying, check the specific product listing and make sure the drives you plan to use are compatible.

    You’ll need to fit compatible drives; for 2.5-inch drives, the DS223j also requires the appropriate holder.

Key brands to consider

QNAP

The TS-233 is worth considering if you regularly receive materials on USB drives.

  • QNAP documents a USB port and a copy button for a configurable copying task on the TS-233.
  • Synchronisation mode can remove files from the destination. You’ll need to check the copy mode, direction and result.

Synology

The DS223j combines network storage with USB Copy, and Synology lists this model as supported.

  • Synology lists two drive bays and local access options for the DS223j. A correctly configured USB Copy task can transfer files between the NAS and an external drive.
  • USB Copy requires a recognised drive and a suitable task. According to Synology, 2.5-inch drives need a separate holder.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is a two-bay option for local network storage, with USB ports.

  • ASUSTOR lists two drive bays, USB ports and SMB file sharing for this model.
  • If copying with a button is important to you, check that the AS1102TL specifically supports this feature. You can’t assume that a feature on another ASUSTOR model will also be available on this one.

Joybuy products

The Joybuy product in this section is a NAS for local network sharing and keeping workshop materials in one shared location.

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS with eight drive bays

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS, 8 bays, dual 2.5GbE, optional 10GbE, up to 360TB

As a NAS for local network sharing and shared files, this model is a good fit for centralised storage.

Eight drive bays and two built-in 2.5GbE ports; 10GbE is optional. The stated capacity is up to 360TB. Compatible drives must be fitted in the bays.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I copy files to a NAS without storing them with an external cloud provider?

Yes. Local network storage and copying via USB are different from external cloud storage. Synology lists the DS223j as supporting USB Copy, and QNAP documents a USB copy button for the TS-233. Whether you can complete the initial set-up entirely without an internet connection is a separate question.

Can I synchronise a USB stick without worrying about losing files?

No, not without checking the mode first. In the synchronisation mode documented by QNAP, files are removed from the destination if they’re missing from the source. First, test the copy direction and destination folder using unimportant files.

Are two mirrored NAS hard drives enough for a backup?

No. The BSI distinguishes RAID mirroring from data backup, because simultaneous changes can affect errors too. Plan a separate copy and check that you can restore files from it.

Do I need to buy a particular NAS model to comply with the GDPR?

No, the requirements don’t specify a particular model across the board. If the GDPR applies to your use and you process personal data, you must take account of a legal basis and appropriate technical and organisational measures. Having a NAS on your own network doesn’t automatically meet these requirements. The German Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information explains these obligations in relation to the processing involved.

Are hard drives included with the NAS enclosure?

It depends on the specific product listing. Synology doesn’t list any hard drives as included with the DS223j; a separate holder is required for 2.5-inch drives. Check the product variant and drive compatibility.